Instant Access to the Journals You Need

for just $40 per month.

Start Your Free Trial

Siger of Brabant and Thomas Aquinas on Divine Power and the Separability of Accidents

Siger of Brabant and Thomas Aquinas on Divine Power and the Separability of Accidents


I wish to examine an excerpt from Siger of Brabant's Questions on the Book of Causes that has already received considerable attention on the part of scholars. 1 The text is remarkable for its criticism of Aquinas's doctrine that God can conserve an accident independently from the substance in which it naturally inheres, as he does in the case of the Eucharist. While Siger is careful not to question the validity and indeed the absolute certainty of the Eucharist as a theological truth, he is critical about the claim that God's being able to make accidents subsist independently from substance can be demonstrated or shown to be true by relying solely on the use of natural reason: 'Some people argue fallaciously believing that they can show and demonstrate by natural reason that the first cause can make it (come to pass) that the accident can exist without the subject of that accident.' 2 To understand Siger's scepticism on this issue we must turn to his Questions on Aristotle's Metaphysics , where he lists six differences between theology and philosophy, only the first four of which need concern us here. The first difference concerns the methodologies, or 'modes of
Loading next page...

You're reading a free preview. Subscribe to read the entire article.

And millions more from thousands of peer-reviewed journals, for only $40/month.

Start Your Free Trial

What content is in DeepDyve?

  • Read and share from thousands of the leading scholarly journals from Springer, Elsevier, Nature, IEEE, Wiley-Blackwell and more.
  • All the latest content is available, no embargo periods.

Rent Scholarly Articles?

  • Read the full article in your browser.
  • Access all of your rentals from the cloud anywhere you have an internet connection.
  • Beautiful reading experience – Full charts and figures, just like the PDF.
  • Read as much as you'd like - whenever you'd like.

Happy Users

“In one word renting from DeepDyve is FANTASTIC!!! ... 99% of the time I only need access to an article for a month or so, so renting the articles is perfect for me.”

Adam S.

“Thanks for a great service! For an unaffiliated science blogger like myself this is like a dream come true.”

Seppo P.

“Hi guys, I cannot tell you how much I love this resource. Incredible. I really believe you've hit the nail on the head with this site in regards to solving the research-purchase issue.”

Daniel C.

“Let me seize this opportunity and congratulate you on the service you are rendering to the scientific community.”

Joao B.