“Woah! It's like Spotify but for academic articles.”

Instant Access to Thousands of Journals for just $40/month

Get 2 Weeks Free

Plato’s Cyclical Argument for the Immortality of the Soul

Plato’s Cyclical Argument for the Immortality of the Soul Introduction Plato's Phaedo contains four different arguments for the immortality of the soul. The first of these, known as the "Cyclical Argument", occurs at 70c4-72e2. Its central claim is that the living come from the dead or, as J. Wolfe has concisely put it, that "every incarnation is a reincarnation".1 Thus the soul's existence is marked by a 'cycle' in which it alternates between coming-to-be united with and separated from some body. In turn, this claim is meant to support the idea that the soul does not perish with the body at the time of the person's death. The Cyclical Argument is commonly considered to be the weakest of all the arguments for the immortality of the soul that Plato ever gives -- whether in the Phaedo or elsewhere. Among its harshest critics, J. Wolfe held that, whether valid or invalid, it does not establish the immortality of the soul but at best "would succeed in proving bodily and only bodily survival!"2 Other critics, like C. J. F. Williams and D. Gallop, believe the argument to be question-begging on the ground that it unduly presupposes a distinction between living and existing.3 J. Barnes has claimed that the argument http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie de Gruyter

Loading next page...
 
/lp/de-gruyter/plato-s-cyclical-argument-for-the-immortality-of-the-soul-0E4tXOu6K0

You're reading a free preview. Subscribe to read the entire article.

And millions more from thousands of peer-reviewed journals, for just $40/month

Get 2 Weeks Free

To be the best researcher, you need access to the best research

  • With DeepDyve, you can stop worrying about how much articles cost, or if it's too much hassle to order — it's all at your fingertips. Your research is important and deserves the top content.
  • Read from thousands of the leading scholarly journals from Springer, Elsevier, Nature, IEEE, Wiley-Blackwell and more.
  • All the latest content is available, no embargo periods.

Stop missing out on the latest updates in your field

  • We’ll send you automatic email updates on the keywords and journals you tell us are most important to you.
  • There is a lot of content out there, so we help you sift through it and stay organized.