V0L 21 # 3 - - - 5 p r ~ n 9 92 516CUE 0U7L00K C5CL: Exper1ence 1n the C1a55r00rn ne1 1 hp0C1a0 1eer19ye 5aaeennh0aet1 C0mputerpane15upp0rtwa5 ex-f0 e1r 016mvLa n55 htv6e1etefry5 e t n tmth W0rk5h0P0 tn v1tf h t0 r u5ed 1n educat10na1 5ett1n95.7h15 t0p1c wa5 taken up f1r5t 6ecau5e we h0ped t0 pr0v1de c1ear examp1e5 0f c011a60rat10n techn0109y t0 he1p f0cu5 0ur 1ater d15cu5510n5. 7he t ¢n-5t paper, wr1tten 6y 5he11ey 601dman, de5cr16e5 an ethn0meth0d01091ca15tudy 0f team5 0fh19h 5ch001 phy51c5 5tudent5 w0rk1n9 thr0u9h an 0pt1c5 pr061em u51n9 mater1a15 deve10ped 1n the Dyna9ram5 Pr0ject. A1th0u9h 5he and her c011ea9ue5 were 100k1n9 f0r ev1dence 0f team d15cu5510n0n a c0nceptua11eve1, they d15c0vered that the 9r0up d15cu5510n wa5 d0m1nated 6y 50e1a11nteract10n. 5he ar9ue5 that th1515 n0t nece55ar11y 6ad, and 1n fact, may 6e an 1mp0rtant c0mp0nent 0f 9r0up pr061em 501v1n9. 7he 5ec0nd paper 6y Jame5 Lev1n d15cu55e5 the deve10pment 0f ¢ ¢te1e-ta5k f0rce5, ¢ ¢ c0n515t1n9 0f 5tudent5, teacher5 and adu1t5 w1th 5pec1a1expert15e, wh0 w0rk c00perat1ve1y 0ver w1de-area netw0rk5 0n 5pec1f1ed pr061em5. He de5cr16e5 the 1mp0rtance 0f ¢ ¢med1at0r5 ¢ ¢ t0 the5e 9r0up5 and 5u99e5t5 h0w c0mputer6a5ed t0015 c0u1d 6e de519ned t0 5upp0rt the med1at0r5. Den15 Newman ¢5 paper de5cr16e5 the Earth La6 Pr0ject, deve10ped f0r teach1n9 5c1ence t0 e1ementary 5ch001 5tudent5 and u5ed 0ver an extended per10d 0f t1me 1n a New Y0rk c1ty 5ch001. He ra15e5 the p01nt that C5CL pr0ject5 may w0rk 6etter 1fn0t c0n5tra1ned t0 f1t w1th1n trad1t10na1 academ1c ca1endar5 and pr0v1de5 tw0 ar9ument5. F1r5t, pr0ject5 wh1ch are a110wed t0 extend 0ver m0re than 0ne academ1c year 6e91n t0 re5em61e apprent1ce5h1p5 and w0rk 1n the n0n-academ1c w0r1d. 5ec0nd 1fapr0ject 15extended 0ver m0re than 0ne year, the eff0rt 0f 1eam1n9 C5CL t0015 can 6e am0rt12ed 0ver the c0ur5e 0f the wh01e pr0ject. Mar9aret R1e1 ¢5 paper de5cr16e5 the ph11050phy 6eh1nd the Learn1n9 C1rc1e pr0ject5 0n the A7 ¢7 Learn1n9 Netw0rk. Leam1n9 C1rc1e pr0ject5 1nv01ve mu1t1p1e c1a55r00m5 at d1fferent 51te5 w0rk1n9 c011a60rat1ve1y 0n a c0mm0n pr0ject v1a a w1de-area netw0rk. Up0n c0mp1et10n 0f the pr0ject, a11 c1a55r00m5 part1c1pate 1n the pr0duct10n 0f a pr0ject rep0rt that 15d15tr16uted t0 a11 0f the 5tudent5. Mar9aret wa5 n0t a61e t0 pre5ent her paper at the W0rk5h0p, 6ut we were p1ea5ed t0 6e a61e t0 1nc1ude 1t 1n the c011ect10n. Randa11 8.5m1th ¢5 art1c1e 1ntr0duce5 a new acr0nym, WY51W17Y5 5tand1n9 f0r ¢ ¢What Y0u 5ee 15 What 1 7h1nk Y0u 5ee. ¢ ¢ WY51W17Y5 15 a 1e55 re5tr1ct1ve de519n pr1nc1p1e than WY51W15 (What Y0u 5ee 15 What 1 5ee). He 90e5 0n t0 de5cr16e h0w C 5 C L techn0109y c0u1d attempt t0 5upp0rt WY51W17Y5. He deve10ped 5uch a 5y5tem, 5haredARK, atXer0x PARC and u5ed exper1menta11y w1th 5tudent5 at Rank-Xer0x Re5earch Center 1n Cam6r1d9e, U.K. U51n9 5haredARK, 5tudent5 can w0rk c00perat1ve1y w1th1n a 5hared phy51c5 m1cr0w0r1d, even th0u9h they are phy51ca11y 5eparated 6y 9reat d15tance5. 7he paper51n the pane1 were 5e1ected t0 5h0w the ran9e 0f C5CL app11cat10n5. Newman ¢5 Earth La6 Pr0ject 15 an examp1e 0f a C5CL parad19m 1n that 1t wa5 6a5ed 0n a 10ca1 area netw0rk u5ed w1th1n a c1a55r00m. Lev1n ( ¢ ¢7e1e-ta5k f0rce ¢ ¢), R1e1( ¢ ¢Learn1n9 C1rc1e5 ¢ ¢), and 5m1th ( ¢ ¢5haredARK ¢ ¢) de5cr16e netw0rk app11cat10n5 that e1ther 0perate 6etween c1a55r00m5 0r that 6r1n9 new 1earn1n9 re50urce5 1nt0 the c1a55r00m thr0u9h w1de-area netw0rk5. 601dman ¢5 paper pr0v1de5 an examp1e 0f c0mputer-6a5ed mater1a15 that 5upp0rt c011a60rat10n 6ut that d0 n0t depend 0n a netw0rk 0f any k1nd. What 61nd5 the5e paper5 t09ether 15n0t apart1cu1ar f0rm 0f techn0109y, 6ut rather a c0nnect10n t0 a f0rm 0f 1n5truct10n that 15 6a5ed up0n team5 0f 5tudent5 w0rk1n9 t09ether c011a60rat1ve1y. 7he term ¢ ¢9r0upware ¢ ¢ ha5 6een c01ned f0r 50ftware that 15 meant t0 6e u5ed 6y 9r0up5 rather than 51n91e1nd1v1dua15.1n pract1ce 9r0upware ha5 c0me t0 mean pr09ram5 that fac111tate9r0up 1nteract10n5 e1ther 1n face-t0-face meet1n95 0r when c0mmun1cat1n9 a5ynchr0n0u51y (e.9., thr0u9h e-ma11). 8ecau5e C5CL 1nv01ve5 a 5pec1a1 k1nd 0f 9r0u1r---team5 0f 1eamer5--1t ha5 5pec1a1 re4u1rement5 that 90 6ey0nd 51mp1y fac111tat1n9c0mmun1cat10n. 70 under5tand h0w t0 de519n 50ftware f0r c011a60rat1ve 1earn1n9, 0ne mu5t f~r5t under5tand the 1n5truct10na1 ph11050phy under1y1n9 th15 appr0ach t0 1eam1n9.

/lp/association-for-computing-machinery/cscl-experience-in-the-classroom-npjP8KGOzo